Current:Home > StocksNYU Researchers Were Studying Disinformation On Facebook. The Company Cut Them Off -TradeGrid
NYU Researchers Were Studying Disinformation On Facebook. The Company Cut Them Off
View
Date:2025-04-15 03:41:02
Facebook has blocked a team of New York University researchers studying political ads and COVID-19 misinformation from accessing its site, a move that critics say is meant to silence research that makes the company look bad.
The researchers at the NYU Ad Observatory launched a tool last year to collect data about the political ads people see on Facebook. Around 16,000 people have installed the browser extension. It enables them to share data with the researchers about which ads the users are shown and why those ads were targeted at them.
Facebook said on Tuesday that it had disabled the researchers' personal accounts, pages, apps and access to its platform.
"NYU's Ad Observatory project studied political ads using unauthorized means to access and collect data from Facebook, in violation of our terms of service," Mike Clark, Facebook's product management director, wrote in a blog post.
He said Facebook took action "to stop unauthorized scraping and protect people's privacy" in compliance with an agreement it reached with the Federal Trade Commission in 2019, when it paid a $5 billion penalty stemming from the Cambridge Analytica data privacy scandal.
But on Wednesday, the researchers said they're not gathering private information about Facebook users.
"We really don't collect anything that isn't an ad, that isn't public, and we're pretty careful about how we do it," said Laura Edelson, a doctoral candidate at NYU who helps lead the research project and whose account Facebook disabled. She noted that the code for the browser extension is public and that it has been reviewed by outside experts.
Facebook says the browser extension violates its privacy rules because it collects information about advertisers, including their names, Facebook IDs and photos. The company says the data collected by the tool could also be used to identify information about users who interacted with the ads but did not consent to share their information.
Damon McCoy, an associate professor at NYU who was also cut off from Facebook, said he believes the company is using privacy claims as a pretext because it's unhappy with the team's research.
"It feels like Facebook is trying to intimidate us, and not just us, but they're trying to send a message to other independent researchers that are trying to study their platform," he said. "We need transparency and accountability."
Research revealed Facebook's failures ahead of 2020 election
NYU Cybersecurity for Democracy, the team of researchers behind the Ad Observatory project, found misleading political ads thriving on Facebook in November 2020 despite the platform's policies; uncovered flaws in the company's political ad disclosures; and tracked the degree to which right-wing misinformation gets more engagement on the platform. They are also part of a project that is tracking false claims about COVID-19 and vaccines on social media, a subject that has become a source of tension between Facebook and the White House in recent weeks.
"This is sort of a blind men and an elephant problem," Edelson said.
To gain a more complete picture of disinformation on Facebook, she said, "we really need to be able to put the pieces together, from the way ads that advertise a certain message are publicized to the way they're targeted" to messages that aren't ads but that are posted by people looking to spread false information in a coordinated way.
Facebook publishes its own library of political ads with information about who paid for an ad and when it ran, but it does not include details on how ads are targeted to specific subsets of users. It does make ad targeting data available to researchers who participate in a program it controls.
In the blog post, Facebook's Clark said that the company offers researchers "privacy-protective methods to collect and analyze data" and that "we welcome research that holds us accountable, and doesn't compromise the security of our platform or the privacy of the people who use it."
The NYU researchers say their work is an important independent check on Facebook.
"We don't think Facebook should get to decide who gets to study it and who doesn't," Edelson said.
Facebook declined to comment further on Edelson and McCoy's claims.
Congress urged to require more transparency in online ads
On Wednesday, Sen. Mark Warner, D-Va., called Facebook's decision to disable the NYU team's access "deeply concerning."
"For several years now, I have called on social media platforms like Facebook to work with, and better empower, independent researchers, whose efforts consistently improve the integrity and safety of social media platforms by exposing harmful and exploitative activity," he said in a statement. "Instead, Facebook has seemingly done the opposite."
Warner also called on Congress "to act to bring greater transparency to the shadowy world of online advertising."
Fellow Democrat Sen. Ron Wyden of Oregon also slammed the social network, writing in a Twitter post: "After years of abusing users' privacy, it's rich for Facebook to use it as an excuse to crack down on researchers exposing its problems."
Wyden said he had contacted the FTC to ask about Facebook's claim that it was concerned the NYU tool violated its privacy order, calling that excuse "bogus."
The FTC declined to comment.
Ramya Krishnan, a staff attorney at Columbia University's Knight First Amendment Institute, said Facebook's decision to cut off the NYU team illustrates how powerful the platform has become — and why lawmakers need to act.
"The company functions as a gatekeeper to journalism and research about how the company's platform works and the impact of its platform on society. And we think that that is untenable," she said. "The public urgently needs to know and needs to understand the implications of Facebook's platform for public discourse and democracy."
The Knight Institute, which is representing NYU's Edelson and McCoy in this matter, urged Facebook back in 2018 to create a "safe harbor" provision in its terms of service that would allow academics and journalists to research and collect data from its platform, while protecting users' privacy. But, Krishnan, said negotiations with the company ended in a stalemate.
Now, she said, the solution lies in Washington. She says Congress should "mandate transparency" on social media platforms and create a safe harbor law protecting research.
"We're not saying that Facebook doesn't have legitimate reasons for, in general, prohibiting scraping," she said. "But intentionally or not, those prohibitions are also impeding journalists' and researchers' ability to study, understand and report about the platform."
Editor's note: Facebook is among NPR's financial supporters.
veryGood! (37)
Related
- Scoot flight from Singapore to Wuhan turns back after 'technical issue' detected
- U.S. journalist Evan Gershkovich's trial resumes in Russia on spying charges roundly denounced as sham
- Russell Westbrook expected to join Nuggets after Clippers-Jazz trade
- Harvey Weinstein's New York sex crimes retrial set to begin in November
- 'Kraven the Hunter' spoilers! Let's dig into that twisty ending, supervillain reveal
- Rare orange lobster, found at Red Lobster, gets cool name and home at Denver aquarium
- NFL Hall of Famer Lawrence Taylor charged with failing to update address on sex offender registry
- Blinken points to wider pledges to support Ukraine in case US backs away under Trump
- Person accused of accosting Rep. Nancy Mace at Capitol pleads not guilty to assault charge
- Last finalist ends bid to lead East Baton Rouge Parish Schools
Ranking
- 2 killed, 3 injured in shooting at makeshift club in Houston
- NASA plans for space station's demise with new SpaceX Deorbit Vehicle
- Carol Burnett honors friend Bob Newhart with emotional tribute: 'As kind and nice as he was funny'
- Mississippi’s new Episcopal bishop is first woman and first Black person in that role
- Who are the most valuable sports franchises? Forbes releases new list of top 50 teams
- WNBA All-Star Weekend: Schedule, TV, rosters
- Former postal worker sentenced to probation for workers’ compensation fraud
- El Paso man sentenced to 19 years for shooting at border patrol agent
Recommendation
Woman dies after Singapore family of 3 gets into accident in Taiwan
Blinken points to wider pledges to support Ukraine in case US backs away under Trump
American Airlines has a contract deal with flight attendants, and President Biden is happy about it
FedEx, UPS warn deliveries may be delayed due to Microsoft outage
All That You Wanted to Know About She’s All That
American Airlines has a contract deal with flight attendants, and President Biden is happy about it
A man kills a grizzly bear in Montana after it attacks while he is picking berries
Shane Lowry keeps calm and carries British Open lead at Troon