Current:Home > reviewsEducators say they are working with, not against, AI in the classroom -TradeGrid
Educators say they are working with, not against, AI in the classroom
View
Date:2025-04-13 04:44:26
Come fall, there will be a new student in many classrooms: A version of artificial intelligence, or a large language model (LLM) like ChatGPT that can mimic human intelligence.
While several school districts have outright banned students from using AI, other institutions are asking teachers to use their own discretion. And rather than trying to work against AI, some educators are willingly bringing it into the classroom.
"My opinion is that it is my obligation and responsibility to expose and immerse students in these generative AI tools," Dan Wang, a sociology professor at Columbia Business School told CBS MoneyWatch. He said the university has left it up to instructors to decide how to work with or against AI.
For his part, Wang is encouraging, and even requiring that his students use AI to complete their coursework.
- AI has a giant carbon footprint. Can the technology also fight climate change?
- Nvidia riding high on explosive growth in AI
- Rise of AI has actors fearing for their jobs
"The reason why is because the MBA students I teach are going to be entering the workforce in about 10 months, and they'll often be working within companies and organizations that encourage employees to make use of generative AI tools," Wang said.
Benefits and constraints
Wang noted that he has colleagues who have taken the opposite tack, choosing instead to restrict students from using AI as much as possible.
But Wang considers that to be a losing battle on multiple fronts. For one, he says the technology is impossible to completely rein in. Second, he believes in attempting to do so, he would be doing his students a disservice.
"The classroom is the place to help students understand the advantages and benefits of tools and, through their own use of them, their constraints," Wang said. "The more students understand what they can and can't use these tools for, the more comfortable they'll be doing so in the workplace."
Assignments he gives require students to use AI platforms as research assistants, for example.
"In my class, most assignments and exercises done in class and outside feature some aspect of generative AI that's required," he said. "They range from interaction with personas that have been trained on custom generative AI models and using AI as a creative assistant."
What he won't do, however, is rely on AI to grade or otherwise evaluate his students' work.
"I want students to know I care a lot about their work and I'm giving every attention I can spare to the work they submit," he said.
"Dead-end game"
Graham Glass, an AI expert and founder and CEO of Cypher Learning, a company that provides AI-powered learning platforms for school and businesses, agrees that trying to curb AI's use is a losing battle.
The solution, as he sees it, is to "change how student work is evaluated."
"Vetting a student essay phrase by phrase, searching for pilfered or artificially manufactured language, is a dead-end game," he told CBS MoneyWatch. "There is no payoff in a tit-for-tat escalatory conflict pitting crafty students against overworked instructors. Students will always be tempted to 'let ChatGPT do it,' and no policing software will be an airtight deterrent."
He advises instructors to consider how AI can be an additive.
"I think enlightened educators will say things like, 'a requirement of this course is that you use AI, because the kinds of assessments I will give you, you can't do without it.'"
If he were teaching a class, as opposed to assigning students an essay to write, Glass would ask them to write a book, with the help of an AI assistant, of course.
"I'd say write an entire book with 15 chapters, an epilogue, prologue, and get five other students in the class to review it for originality, believability and writing style," Glass said.
This will force students to think creatively about how to employ AI, including what prompts to feed it.
"It gets them used to what's possible when humans team up with AI," Glass said. "It pushes them to be more creative than ever before, while also preparing them for the age of AI."
veryGood! (452)
Related
- Bodycam footage shows high
- Biden says striking UAW workers deserve fair share of the benefits they help create for automakers
- IMF warns Lebanon that the country is still facing enormous challenges, years after a meltdown began
- Warnock calls on Atlanta officials to be more transparent about ‘Stop Cop City’ referendum
- The Super Bowl could end in a 'three
- Lil Guy, a Florida alligator missing his top jaw, rescued after finding online fame
- Lawsuit alleges sexual assault during Virginia Military Institute overnight open house
- Man gets 15 years to life for killing commuter he shoved into moving train in unprovoked attack
- Appeals court scraps Nasdaq boardroom diversity rules in latest DEI setback
- Ashton Kutcher resigns as chair of anti-sex abuse organization after Danny Masterson letter
Ranking
- Are Instagram, Facebook and WhatsApp down? Meta says most issues resolved after outages
- They worked for years in Libya. Now an Egyptian village mourns scores of its men killed in flooding
- 13 Sales You'll Regret Not Shopping This Weekend: Free People, Anthropologie, Kate Spade & More
- Former top US diplomat sentenced in Qatar lobbying scheme
- Bodycam footage shows high
- See Ariana Madix Lay Down the Law in Trailer for Her First Acting Role Since Scandoval
- Rep. Adam Smith calls GOP-led impeachment inquiry against Biden a ridiculous step - The Takeout
- The cost of damage from the record floods in Greece’s breadbasket is estimated to be in the billions
Recommendation
Who's hosting 'Saturday Night Live' tonight? Musical guest, how to watch Dec. 14 episode
Satellite images show large-scale devastation of Libya's floods
North Korean arms for Russia probably wouldn’t make a big difference in the Ukraine war, Milley says
Hugh Jackman and wife Deborra-lee separate after 27 years of marriage
Former Danish minister for Greenland discusses Trump's push to acquire island
Watch: TSA agents in Miami appear to steal passenger items; what they're accused of taking
Birmingham church bombing survivor reflects on 60th anniversary of attack
You can pre-order the iPhone 15 Friday. Here's what to know about the new phones.